Best Lawyers
Multi Million Dollar
Super Lawyers

FINRA Fines American Trust Investment Services Broker John James Hoidas

Banks Law Office

On July 7, 2023, FINRA issued an AWC (Acceptance, Waiver, and Consent) sanctioning American Trust Investment Services’ broker John James Hoidas. Hoidas was assessed a deferred fine of $40,000 and suspended from association with any FINRA member in all capacities for 18 months. He did not admit or deny the findings but consented to the sanctions and the following findings:

  1. Hoidas made unsuitable recommendations in speculative alternative investments to customers of his member firm, which were inconsistent with the customers’ investment profiles.
  2. Hoidas borrowed $10,000 from one of his firm’s customers without providing prior written notice or obtaining written approval from the firm. When he failed to repay the loan, the customer complained, leading to a settlement with the customer.
  3. Hoidas caused two member firms he was associated with to maintain incomplete books and records. He communicated with firm customers via text messages on his personal phone, which the firm had not approved as a permissible electronic communications channel, thus failing to capture or maintain these text message communications as required.
  4. While registered with another firm, Hoidas entered into a commission-sharing agreement with another firm’s registered representative, which was neither disclosed to nor approved by the firm. This action caused the firm to fail to comply with its recordkeeping obligations due to unauthorized and undisclosed compensation through the commission-sharing agreement.

If you lost money because of Hoiadas’s investment recommendations, please contact Banks Law Office.

Client Reviews

I had no clue where to turn for help. Banks was tough but polite. I give the man my total respect and unlimited endorsement. To me, he achieved the impossible.


Thank you for all you did to represent us. For me you represent all that is good in the Law profession. You were honest, fair, hard working, and ethical. What more can you ask? Once again thank you for all you did.


Hope you have had a great year and we wish you and yours the best in the Holiday season. We fondly and gratefully remember all the efforts you made on behalf of N*** and I. Without a doubt our lives have been changed forever by meeting you.

A Banks Law Client, 8 years later

No Recovery, No Fee

Fill out the contact form or call us at 503-222-7475 to schedule your free consultation.

Leave Us a Message